westway asphalt
Guide · Comparisons

Tarmac vs block paving vs resin driveways

By Peter Priest, Director, Westway Asphalt · Updated

Short answer

Tarmac is usually the cheapest and quickest to lay and the best for heavy use. Block paving gives the most choice of look and can be lifted and relaid. Resin gives a smooth decorative finish but usually costs most. On a good base, all three can last 15 to 20 years or more.

Side-by-side comparison

TarmacBlock pavingResin-bound
Cost per m²Usually the lowestMid to highUsually the highest
Time to layFastestSlowest: each block laid by handMedium, weather-dependent
LookPlain, dark, uniformPatterns and coloursSmooth stone finish, many colours
LifespanTypically 15–20+ yearsTypically 20+ yearsTypically 15–20 years
RepairsPatch repairs blend in over timeLift and relay individual blocksHard to patch invisibly
WeedsVery few on a good baseCan grow in jointsVery few
DrainageImpermeable unless porous asphaltPermeable versions availablePermeable when laid on an open base
Heavy vehiclesGood, with the right build-upGoodBest for cars only

General guide only. Lifespan depends far more on the base and drainage than on the surface.

Tarmac

Tarmac, or asphalt, is laid hot in two layers over a compacted stone base and rolled. It is the quickest and usually cheapest hard driveway per square metre, takes vans and heavy vehicles well, and can be repaired in patches. The downside is looks: it is plain and dark. Coloured asphalt and granite or block edging help.

Standard tarmac is impermeable, so a front driveway has to drain onto your own land, or be laid as porous asphalt, to avoid needing planning permission.

Block paving

Concrete or clay blocks laid on sand over a stone base. It gives the most choice of pattern and colour, and single blocks can be lifted and relaid. It takes longest to lay, weeds and moss can grow in the joints, and blocks can sink or rut if the base is thin. Permeable block paving, with gritted gaps and an open base, avoids the planning issue.

Resin

Resin-bound driveways mix stone with resin and trowel it smooth over a base. They look high-end and come in many colours, and are permeable when laid on an open base. They are usually the most expensive, sensitive to weather when laid, and hard to patch without the repair showing. Resin-bonded, where stone is scattered onto a resin coat, is a different, looser finish and is not permeable.

Planning and drainage

Whichever you choose, a front driveway over 5 m² must be permeable or drain onto your own land, or it needs planning permission. All three can meet the rule: porous asphalt, permeable block paving, or resin-bound on an open base, or any of them drained to a lawn, border or soakaway.

Planning permission explained

Which should you choose?

  • Choose tarmac for value, speed, heavy vehicles, long drives and private roads
  • Choose block paving for pattern and colour, and if you want to be able to lift and relay sections
  • Choose resin for a smooth, decorative finish on a car-only driveway, if the budget allows

We only lay tarmac and asphalt, so we will tell you honestly if one of the others suits your house better.

Questions

Which driveway lasts longest?

On a properly built base, all three can last 15 to 20 years or more. Most driveways fail because of a thin sub-base or poor drainage, not the surface material.

Which is cheapest?

Usually tarmac, per square metre, because it is quick to lay. The dig-out and base cost about the same for all three.

Can I put tarmac next to block paving?

Yes. A block paving border around a tarmac driveway is a popular way to get a neater look for less.

Talk to a contractor who lays it

Tell us about your job and we will arrange a visit and a written quote.

Get my free quote
Get a free quote